Exercise 01

Reading a scientific paper

Dates

Due: Friday, August 31.

Goals

This exercise gives you an opportunity to apply some of the ideas we discussed in class about how to read a scientific paper.

Assignment

You may work with one other person if you wish. Choose a paper you find interesting.

Use the rubric described in (Carey, Steiner, & Petri, 2020) to read the paper.

Answer the following specific questions in “Rule 3” of (Carey et al., 2020):

  1. What do the author(s) want to know (motivation)?
  2. What did they do (approach/methods)?
  3. Why was it done that way (context within the field)?
  4. What do the results show (figures and data tables)?
  5. How did the author(s) interpret the results (interpretation/discussion)?
  6. What should be done next? (Regarding this last question, the author(s) may provide some suggestions in the discussion, but the key is to ask yourself what you think should come next.)

(Carey et al., 2020)

If it’s an empirical paper, pay particular attention to what evidence, usually a pattern of data, the author(s) use to argue for a particular finding or conclusion. Is there a figure that demonstrates this well? If so, how? If not, why not?

Tip

If you’re struggling to decide how to start your paper, that is how to write the introduction, imagine that you are giving your paper to a friend or colleague. What would they want to know about what your write-up is about and why they should read it?

When I was in high school, my English teacher, Ms. Sinard advised us to start every essay with “When”, “If”, or “Although”. It’s not bad advice, especially if you’re stuck.

Submit

A 2-3 page (double-spaced) paper describing your findings in Microsoft Word format using the following file-naming convention:

<lastname>-<firstname>-PSYCH490.009-ex01.docx, where you substitute your last name for and your first name for . If there are two authors, use both of your last names. If Dr. Gilmore was submitting a paper, it would look like this: gilmore-rick-PSYCH490.009-ex01.docx.

Here is the Canvas dropbox for the assignment:

https://psu.instructure.com/courses/2280122/assignments/15452006

Please use the APA format for your paper. I found the following template document that would be a very good start:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1IIKwtH7eVXIkQMz4FwMuKol6hMDT3ra9/copy

References

Carey, M. A., Steiner, K. L., & Petri, W. A., Jr. (2020). Ten simple rules for reading a scientific paper. PLoS Computational Biology, 16(7), e1008032. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1008032